Many people believe schools ought to start later, but what are the advantages of starting school earlier? I do not notice a difference between later and earlier start times for school. Unless your school starts earlier than 8 am, a later start will not improve anything, but will more likely make things worse.
Students and educators contend that by delaying the start of classes, they would get more sleep. According to my findings, I’ve found that if school starts later, individuals will just use it as an excuse to stay up longer and put off doing their work more frequently. The majority of people who finish their assignments at the last minute are procrastinators, so if you offer them more time, they'll just hold back more. Even though there might be less tardiness, I think that if school started later, after-school programs would start later as well. Louis Gaillie believes that resuming after-school activities like athletics, theater, and other lessons would be a disadvantage to starting school later. Sports and other after-school activities may already have practices that last until 6:00 p.m. and tournaments that last until 8:00 p.m. These would be further delayed. Students already leave certain afternoon classes at schools in large US states to travel to competitions. If start times were pushed back, the number of days these students would miss school would increase. They may also find themselves with a limited amount of time each day to complete their work. This would force them to stay up later to complete their work, negating the benefits of having a later start time. Even if some teenagers have no extracurricular activities after school, the temptation to stay up later each night because they can sleep in later the next morning exists. Starting school later would merely mean shifting the schedule back. Simply moving things backward won't provide people extra time or sleep. Leigh Ann Morgan asserts that getting more sleep would benefit both physical and mental health, academic performance, and the reduction of teen wrecks. Unless you reduce the amount of time you spend in class, these benefits won't be seen. If not, your schedule is merely being advanced by an hour so that it begins and ends later, so you are still getting the same amount of sleep.
Parental problems can also arise from school starting late. Most parents drop off their children on their way to work. It might be difficult to get a child who cannot drive to school without making the parents late for work if school started at the same time as they had to go to work. According to the Master of Arts in Teaching guide, it states “Family schedules have been set up to revolve around school schedules. Making a major switch to later start times may pose a challenge for working parents who would have to deal with additional costs of before and after-school care and transportation. Since most parents revolve around their children, changing the schedule would also pose problems for the parents as well as for the students. Additionally, students would have fewer opportunities to receive tutoring and partake in out-of-school activities if they start school later. Gaille states “Many after-school tutoring programs are operated by volunteers that have finite time resources. Changing the school schedule will change their schedule, which may make it difficult to continue providing services during the week. That would push tutoring needs to the weekend, where more students may be less likely to engage with the service”. This demonstrates how it would influence students' ability to receive extra assistance on challenging courses and make them always occupied, even on weekends. If everything is moved around, there might not be time for extracurricular activities because your schedule would rapidly get full and you wouldn't have time for them.
In my opinion, extending school's start time won't result in more sleep. Why delay extracurricular activities if you still plan to attend school during the same hours as before? The earlier you begin, the sooner you can return home. Students who start school at 7:30 in the morning are the ones who are complaining. I think students would get enough sleep and still have plenty of time for after-school activities if school started at 8 or 8:30, but I don't think it should start at 9. As a result, I believe that starting school too early or too late won't improve anything and will only lead to further issues.
Works Cited
Gaille, Louise. “19
Should School Start Later in the Morning Pros and Cons – Vittana.org.” Vittana.org,
28 Aug. 2018, vittana.org/19-should-school-start-later-in-the-morning-pros-and-cons.
Master of Arts in
Teaching Guide. “5 Pros and Cons of Later School Start Times.” Masterofartsinteaching.net,
2013, www.masterofartsinteaching.net/lists/5-pros-and-cons-of-later-school-start-times/.
Morgan, Leigh. Pros
and Cons of Later School Start Times.
“Studies Support Argument
School Should Start Later.” Coppell Student Media, coppellstudentmedia.com/52886/opinions/studies-support-argument-school-should-start-later/.
Accessed 2 Oct. 2022.
Hi Shriya, I really enjoyed reading your blog! I found it very interesting how you explain that commitments such as school and extracurriculars would remain the same length, only pushed back in time. I think that when many people think of later school start times, they think of earlier end times as well. As you explain though, later start times would most likely just result in inconvenience for parents, sports, and procrastination.
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you included problems with parents being able to take students to school and how activities have to revolve around the school's decisions, which is just unfair.
ReplyDeleteHi Shriya! Your argument for later school times is very solid. Usually more sleep is a big reason for wanting later start times, but you rebuked that really well. Explaining how later school times would only increase procrastination was also interesting.
ReplyDeleteAs a victim of procrastination and sleeping late, I always want to sleep in a little more. However, even if school started later, I could totally see myself procrastinating more, and ending up sleeping later, and it wouldn't be much different from the original schedule. I'm sure that most Uni students have many extracurriculars and busy schedules, and this blog explains very well that changing times will complicate thigs a lot. You've convinced me that changing school times will not help anyone much.
ReplyDelete- Jason
DeleteI like that image. It embodies what late risers feel like. If you do not have a consistent sleeping schedule than going to school later can help. I do not understand the point about the school day starting earlier would help parents work. My parents usually go to work pretty early, but I guess school affects that. I interesting point might be the late start idea because I know some public schools do that and it could be a compromise for the people that need it.
ReplyDeleteI've never actually seen somebody take this stance on this topic before, and I think you brought up some great points! I particularly agree with your point about the parents' life having to move around their children. Uni used to have an earlier start time, and when I was discussing the change with an older student, they said that they still get to school at the same time they did before the change. They get dropped off by their parents who have work that they can't be late to, so they just end up wasting time at school before classes start. Your argument was very compelling, and I think I agree with you!
ReplyDeleteI like the way you describe the complete lack of benefits (and presence of problems instead) that comes with starting school later. At first I would've argued that school should absolutely start later, but your argument is very convincing, and I find myself agreeing with you.
ReplyDeleteWhen I first saw your title, I agreed that school should start later due to the fact that you would "get more sleep". But, you then mentioned how this in reality wouldn't happen and instead there are many consequences to a later start time. You lay out a good variety of arguments with evidence from multiple sources. This blog convinced me that starting school later is not a good idea!
ReplyDeleteHi Shriya! I really enjoyed reading you're blog and I think you made a compelling argument on the subject. As someone who often takes the opposite position, I even found myself a bit convinced as you had really good counter-arguments to things I might say when presented with this question. All of your points are supported by good evidence and reasoning!
ReplyDeleteI first I thought schools should start at a later time but the way you described. The lack of benefits that come with starting school early is really interesting. Such as how procrastinator will just put of the work even longer.
ReplyDeleteThis is a very convincing argument. People often overlook the fact that is school starts later, it will also end later, so I was glad to see it mentioned here. I also thought it was very interesting how changes to start times will affect family schedules, because I had not really thought of that before.
ReplyDeleteYou took an interesting and unexpected side in this argument. I myself am student who would love to sleep in more, and I assumed that you would feel the same, but your argument is very convincing! I hadn't thought about the perspective of procrastination, and how people will only procrastinate more with a later start, but it's a very convincing and accurate argument. Good job!
ReplyDelete